Lawsuit Settlement Taxes
Taxable status of settlements and verdicts is determined based upon the classification of damages received.
Be aware, that the classification of damages is a negotiable item in settlement agreements. In general:
- Recoveries for medical expenses are not taxable.
- Recoveries for physical pain, physical suffering, mental anguish are not taxable.
- Recoveries lost earnings in the past and estimated future lost earnings are taxable.
- Punitive damages (i.e. intended to punish and deter future egregious conduct) received by settlement or verdict are taxable.
Also be aware that the federal circuit tax courts disagree on the taxable status of certain items, and
ultimately, the U.S. Supreme Court is expected to resolve this conflict of laws between regional jurisdictions.
Lawsuit Settlement Taxes - Personal Injury Law :
When evaluating any individual claim, state personal injury law frequently governs when a cause action may be
pursued, the extent of civil responsibility, what recoveries are permitted, and how a cases are presented at
trial. Less often, federal statutes may preempt state laws and require lawsuits to be filed the federal district
court or one of a wide assortment of federal administrative law proceedings, or occasionally allows plaintiffs
to opt for either federal or state court systems. In all individual lawsuits, settlement of civil liability
claims before trial is strongly encouraged by judges to promote judicial economy. For plaintiffs, settlement of
lawsuits is permissive, and may be more advantageous than trial. Settling lawsuits reduces risk, guarantees the
recovery amount, should be contingent upon collection, and saves time, attorney fees, and litigation costs. The
greatest advantage of trial is economic - plaintiffs may receive substantially larger awards in individual
lawsuits from court or jury verdicts than settlement offers.
Application of Law:
The evaluation of facts and applicable personal injury laws is a dynamic process, based upon circumstances
that are personal to each case. Statutes, cases, and rules of evidence and procedure all impact the ultimate
success or failure of each case. Lawyers who specialize in individual lawsuits for plaintiffs interpret laws in
the light most favorable to their client when establishing liability, injuries, compensability, and settlement
terms. Similarly, defense lawyers and insurance adjusters are professionals who are equally talented in
influencing settlement of individual claims far below the true trial value when claimants represents themselves.
|
